Capital ₿’s Alexandre Laizet hosted a talk with TOBAM founder Yves Choueifaty, who treats Bitcoin as base money and judges every treasury by BTC-per-share growth. Check out the full 1 hour conversation right below this article, where they cover mNAV premiums and discounts, Bitcoin-yield mechanics, and how disciplined issuance and buybacks turn thin liquidity into an advantage for teams that disclose, execute, and compound. TOBAM is known for doing deals with both Capital B and Smarter Web Company.
The cornerstone returns
TOBAM’s thesis centers on trust. Gold carried the role but “is not auditable,” the dollar is politicized by design, and the system needs an “unquestionable asset.” In Choueifaty’s phrasing, “there is a small orange entity raising its hand and saying, hey guys, I’m a candidate.” The implication for treasuries is classical: keep the asset side boring (Bitcoin reserves) and do your inventiveness on the liability side.
Treasury math in three terms
TOBAM’s framework decomposes returns of Bitcoin treasury companies into three additive drivers over any horizon:
- Bitcoin yield: growth in BTC per share from accretive capital actions (e.g., buybacks below 1.0 mNAV, issuance above it). This term is mechanical and should be positive under competent management.
- Bitcoin exposure: price sensitivity to BTC that is convex in bull phases as duration and balance-sheet torque compound through time.
- mNAV change: the stochastic part—how far the market prices equity above or below mark-to-treasury value.
The punch line is practical: own teams that reliably elevate BTC per share and let convexity and multiple do the rest.
Liquidity cuts both ways
Summer’s premium compression and sub-1 mNAV prints weren’t a mystery to Choueifaty: thin order books magnify flows. “Those who sell have a strong impact on the price down… those who buy will have a strong impact on the price up.” A BTCtc trading below 1 mNAV isn’t sustainable when the asset is the most liquid collateral in the world; it’s an invitation to disciplined issuers to defend parity with repurchases, then pivot back to premium-funded accumulation when sentiment normalizes.
What makes a treasury investable
TOBAM now runs a 200-point diligence grid. Four pillars recur:
- Purity of model: reserves in Bitcoin, systematic use of proceeds, zero encumbrance, airtight custody, no cash-flow leakage.
- Transparency: frequent, auditable disclosures on BTC per share, issuance, and treasury activity.
- Market discipline: visible premium history, mNAV hygiene, buyback and ATM rules that protect BTC per share through the cycle.
- Power in the cap table and domicile: anchor holders with long duration, seasoned executives in capital markets, and a headquarters/jurisdiction plan that reduces political confiscation risk.
Reflexivity, not romance
The mNAV is a real-time crystallization of expectations for future Bitcoin yield and momentum. Treat it as a variable to manage, not a destiny to lament. Premium is a performance fee earned by execution; discount is a balance-sheet opportunity if the team has the policy tools ready.
Volatility and the single bear case
Volatility is a feature of a project becoming money. The message to holders is austere: size for drawdowns, watch BTC per share, and touch grass. Choueifaty again: “Price is the crystallization of expectations… Don’t look every day at the price.” The only true bear scenario for Bitcoin treasuries? A permanent end to money printing. Otherwise, keep compounding BTC per share.
Signal Take
TOBAM’s lens is the cleanest articulation of how a BTCtc could be run. Keep reserves unassailable, publish the rules of engagement, buy below 1.0 mNAV and issue only when accretive, and let convex exposure to Bitcoin do its work. In a market that still swings between mania and neglect, the edge is execution: compounding BTC per share while managing reflexive premiums with intent. Bitcoin is the monetary base; BTC per share is the score.