VanEck has handed Metaplanet a bad governance grade. Its new review puts the executive option pool at 14.7% of the company’s fully diluted shares.
That’s roughly four times the peer average, Paul Hyde summed up on X. Officer exposure came in at 8.2%, about ten times the norm.
14.7%
The review lands at a bad moment. Metaplanet shares are down more than 43% this year, while bitcoin has lost about 15%. And the company still aims to hold 100,000 bitcoin by the end of 2026.
A cut that didn’t end it
Metaplanet already tried to cool things down. On September 11 the board shrank the option pool from 319.46 million to 188.19 million potential shares.
VanEck’s Matthew Sigel reckons CEO Simon Gerovich gave up about $123 million in the reset. But 82,824,000 shares already handed out were not returned.
- August 28: Gerovich exercises part of his options, lifting his stake to about 79.6 million shares.
- September 11: the board cuts the option pool.
- This week: VanEck publishes its review, and Gerovich answers on X.
Two camps on X
Gerovich pushed back in a Japanese-language post, calling himself a major shareholder who feels the drop personally. Not everyone bought it. Ace Ender called the reply defensive.
Defenders see a pile-on. “There are people who claim to be Metaplanet shareholders with a lot of shares, and yet they use all their daily energies to mock the company,” Enea wrote.
Others want more cuts. Cancelling the 273 million shares created by an anti-dilution clause is “a no-brainer at this point,” Yves-André Graf wrote.
What to watch: whether the board cancels those 273 million shares. And MSCI’s call, due by October 16, on a screen that could drop Metaplanet from its indices.
Signal Take
Metaplanet’s governance problem is now a valuation problem. A company that raises money by selling stock can’t afford investors who think insiders take too big a slice.
What would change our mind: the board cancelling the anti-dilution shares, or MSCI keeping Metaplanet in its indices. Either would take the sting out of VanEck’s grade.