“Progress need not wait for Congress,” Michael Saylor wrote after the Senate killed the CLARITY Act. He meant it as good news.
The bill fell 49 to 50 on 15 September. The House had passed its own version 294 to 134 back in July 2025, and treasury companies mostly shrugged at the collapse.
Saylor’s argument is that the rulebook is coming anyway. He expects the SEC, the CFTC and the Treasury to write rules under laws that already exist, and banks to widen bitcoin custody and lending while they do it.
“Progress need not wait for Congress.”
Michael Saylor
He is not guessing. The CFTC told its staff in August to design a registration category for crypto markets using powers it already has.
Others take the win further. Eric Weiss argued that if clarity means “635 pages of restrictions that bend crypto to the will of traditional finance, we’re better off without it.”
The Problem With Winning This Way
A rule written by an agency can be unwritten by the next one. A chair changes, an administration changes, and the guidance a treasury company built its financing around changes with them.
That is the part Saylor’s framing skips. Legislation is slow because it is hard to undo, and hard to undo is exactly what a company planning a decade of bitcoin purchases wants.
Logan Beirne put the bigger question this way: “what role should government play in deciding which investments companies can make?” He also noted the bill is not quite dead, since a motion to reconsider keeps a path open.
- Large US issuers. Strategy and its peers already sell preferred and convertible paper to institutions. Agency rules that arrive fast are worth more to them than a law that arrives in two years.
- Smaller US treasury companies. They need a predictable path to list a new instrument. Guidance that can be reversed makes every banker they talk to more expensive.
- Non-US issuers. London and Tokyo names do not fall under any of it, but their investors price US regulatory risk anyway, and a US rulebook sets the tone their own regulators borrow from.
Signal Take
Saylor is right about the next twelve months and may be wrong about the next five years. Rules from the SEC and the CFTC will land sooner than any bill, and the companies raising money now will take them gratefully.
The question is what those rules are worth when the people who wrote them leave. A treasury company is a bet measured in decades, and it is now being financed against a rulebook that can be rewritten in a single afternoon.