“What matters most is the net Bitcoin value attributable to each fully diluted Ordinary Share,” Smarter Web’s Andrew Webley wrote on 7 November. He calls it Bitcoin Per Share, or BPS.
Andrew Webley (@asjwebley)
Webley, Smarter Web’s chief executive, means the net figure. It counts bitcoin plus cash, minus debt and preferred stock, divided by every fully diluted ordinary share.
On 7 November, Smarter Web’s analytics page put SWC, its London-listed ordinary shares, at £0.37. Net bitcoin value per fully diluted share was also £0.37.
On 30 September, the price sat £0.26* above that net figure. Now the gap is gone, and that’s the line his rule on issuing shares turns on.
In this piece, BPS means his definition: net. When we mean the figure before debt and preferred, we say gross.
Four points from one letter
- Net beats more. Webley wrote that piling up the largest possible number of coins is not Smarter Web’s main goal. The goal is net value per share.
- More coins can still mean less per share. If holdings grow but new shares or new obligations grow faster, net value per share falls. In that case, he wrote, existing shareholders have not necessarily gained.
- Price decides issuance. He wrote that “issuing shares at the wrong price can be dilutive.” Smarter Web sells new stock through two at-the-market facilities, programmes that sell shares into the market over time. Neither had new issuance on Thursday 5 November, he added.
- Buy back the preferred below its offer price. On 3 November it bought back 1,775 MORE shares at £80.354 each, £142,985 in all. MORE is its sterling preferred share, first offered at £90, with a weekly dividend. They sit in treasury, with no dividends while held.
Webley had already put caution on the ATM in writing in his letter of 31 October. This time he attached a definition to it.
Where the price met the net line
The two lines closed mostly from the top. SWC came down £0.31* between 30 September and 7 November. The net figure came down £0.05*.
One caveat on the starting point. On 30 September, before MORE was issued, the page’s net formula took off debt only. By 14 October, it also took off preferred and added dividend cash.
In sats, the page shows 768 gross and 657 net per fully diluted share on 7 November. The 111 sats* between them are debt plus preferred, minus treasury and dividend cash, priced in bitcoin.
On 7 November, net adds £0.7 million of treasury cash and £2.6 million of dividend cash. Then it takes off £16 million of debt and £10.9 million of preferred.
Bitcoin moves the net figure too. Debt and preferred are fixed in pounds, so they take more sats when bitcoin falls.
The page’s bitcoin price went from £63,034 on 30 September to £56,936 on 7 November, a 9.7%* drop.
Now the maths of issuing at £0.37. A new share sold at that price brings in the £0.37 of net bitcoin value each existing share already holds, before costs. BPS stays where it was.
Strategy splits its scoreboard the same way: 187,443 sats per share gross and 152,531 net on 6 November.
KPI impact, as of 7 November:
- Bitcoin held: 2,850, on 370,852,649 fully diluted shares.
- BPS: 657 net sats, worth £0.37. Gross is 768 sats.
- Capital in: no ATM update since 22 October, and no issuance on 5 November.
- Claims ahead of common: £16 million of debt and £10,936,200 of preferred after the MORE buyback.
- Amplification ratio: 14.5%, the page’s measure of debt plus preferred minus cash, against bitcoin value. It rises when bitcoin falls.
The investor question: will the next share sale clear £0.37?
Webley didn’t promise the share price would follow the net figure. “We cannot control the price of Bitcoin or our equities,” he wrote.
The next ATM update. The last one came on 22 October. Its price against £0.37 is the number that matters.
Another MORE purchase. Any further buyback shows up in the page’s preferred total, now £10,936,200.
Signal Take
We think net is the right scoreboard for Smarter Web, and Webley has now made it the one management answers to. The 768 gross sats look better than 657, but 111 sats* belong to lenders and MORE holders.
The tie at £0.37 turns his rule into arithmetic. Below that line, selling SWC shrinks BPS. Above it, the premium is what grows BPS for existing holders.
The MORE buyback works from the other side of the balance sheet. It takes claims off without adding a share.
At £0.37, a new share adds nothing to BPS.
* Calculated by TreasurySignal from the companies’ figures. Sources: Webley’s letter on X; Smarter Web’s analytics page on 30 September, 14 October and 7 November. Also the MORE buyback notice, Smarter Web’s Investegate page and Strategy’s KPIs of 6 November.