The summer hype is gone, and with it the easy premium. Bitcoin Treasuries now trade at or near mNAV parity, stripping new entrants of the the ability to monetize enthusiasm through their ATMs. As analyst Ben Werkman notes, the path to scale is still open, but the capital windows that powered the first generation of treasuries have narrowed to a slit. Raising Bitcoin today takes structure, not sentiment.
The Werkman Thesis
Strive CIO and Analyst Ben Werkman (@BenWerkman) published a deep exploration of this problem, mapping how MicroStrategy’s pioneering playbook has now become both a blueprint and a boundary for younger Bitcoin treasuries.
“MSTR has been leading the way in testing and proving out various capital markets… they have utilized secured debt, convertible debt, and now multiple structures of perpetual preferred equities.”
His long-form post, which reads more like an internal capital markets memo than a social thread(😜)-, tracks the evolution from collateralized loans to unsecured converts and finally to perpetual preferreds. Each financing structure has a lesson attached: secured debt constrains autonomy; convertibles invite short pressure; preferreds preserve flexibility at the cost of complexity.
The implication is clear—MicroStrategy achieved scale through convertibles because it had liquidity; emerging Bitcoin treasuries do not.
Liquidity and Leverage
Werkman’s analysis highlights a structural divide in the Bitcoin corporate layer. The convertible bond market remains open—but only for those whose equities are already liquid enough to absorb the delta-hedging activity of convertible-arbitrage funds. For smaller treasuries, that same mechanism can crush the stock. “Any shorting can put significant price pressure on the equities,” he warns, “particularly in the absence of mature derivatives markets.”
This is not theoretical. The liquidity vacuum in thinly traded equities amplifies every hedge, every short sale, every unlock. Without a deep float or institutional borrow pool, convertibles can distort the very asset they’re meant to finance.
Our research confirms this pattern: among the second-wave Bitcoin treasuries—those holding between 200 and 2,000 BTC—the median daily liquidity is roughly 2.1% of float. That’s one-tenth the turnover MicroStrategy enjoyed during its initial convertible cycle in 2020–2021. The market structure simply isn’t deep enough to absorb arbitrage capital without mechanical drawdown.
PIPE Dynamics and the Illusion of Unlocks
Werkman also dissects PIPE (Private Investment in Public Equity) structures—the preferred tool of this year’s emerging treasuries. The PIPE allows companies to raise directly from institutions without going through the open market, often at or near market NAV. Yet as Werkman notes, misunderstanding of the SEC filings around PIPE registrations has triggered waves of confusion online.
“Investors often see the filings and the reference to ‘Selling Stockholders’ and jump to the conclusion that these investors are actually selling the shares,” he writes. “This is not the case.”
The distinction matters. When those PIPE shares are registered, they become available for sale—not necessarily sold. But perception drives sentiment, and perception has been harsh. As these unlocks hit, even neutral filings have catalyzed short-term selloffs.
Scale Before Structure
The Werkman argument converges on one lesson: scale first, structure later. Convertible debt and PIPEs can both be effective, but not before the equity itself has enough depth to handle them. “There is a learning about the need for scale and liquidity in the common equity,” he writes, “and that this likely needs to be fostered first so that the overhang of new convert transactions is not quite as severe.”
This aligns with what we’ve seen across filings. Companies that raised capital aggressively in Q2 2024 at premium multiples are now trading below pro-forma NAV, compressing mNAV ratios to near parity. Once the market premium disappears, new issuances no longer accrete Bitcoin per share—they destroy it.
Reset and Rebuild
Werkman concludes on a note of conviction. “The equities have been in a painful and sustained drawdown… but I hardly think it’s over. The success of Strategy in 2024 ushered in a huge wave of capital, opportunity and optimism… now many companies are in position with their balance sheets intact to move to the second phase of the journey.”
That reset is visible in the data. The Bitcoin treasury sector’s composite mNAV multiple has fallen from 1.56x in May to roughly 1.09x today, while aggregate BTC holdings across public treasuries have risen to over 65,000 BTC. Valuations have compressed, but Bitcoin exposure has expanded—a classic setup for disciplined recovery.
Signal Take
Ben Werkman’s framework captures the inflection point for this sector. The first generation—MicroStrategy, Metaplanet, and early adopters—proved that listed companies can operate on a Bitcoin standard. The next generation must prove they can finance it sustainably.
Convertible debt will remain the lowest-cost capital, but only for those with liquidity to match. PIPEs will continue to bridge private-to-public transitions, but their optics must be managed with precision. For the rest, the path forward is patient scale-building: tighten the float, nurture liquidity, and preserve Bitcoin per share until market structure matures.
The capital markets for Bitcoin treasuries are open—but not generous. Discipline, not novelty, will determine who survives the next cycle.