Binance said on 30 October it “has already reserved over $6.34B of company funds to cover this incident.” All deposits and withdrawals were suspended.
For shareholders of bitcoin treasury companies, the Binance hack raises a plainer question. The bitcoin behind each share is only as good as where it is kept and whether it is pledged.
Strategy had 187,753 sats per share on 30 October, a sat being a hundred-millionth of a bitcoin. That number assumes the coins are there and free.
Binance’s first word came on 29 October. It was aware of “reports of a potential security issue” and said “User funds are completely safe.”
It paused withdrawals on 29 October and put the verified total frozen at $2.54 billion. On 30 October it wrote that “Binance will cover all losses” and suspended deposits as well.
Its reserve post of 30 October added: “$5B of these funds are already held in the exact token assets that were impacted.”
Binance (@binance)
The same post says “$3bn has been frozen” and that Binance is buying the remaining token assets “through market channels and OTC channels.”
Four companies, four kinds of answer
- Metaplanet: CEO Simon Gerovich wrote on 30 October: “All of Metaplanet’s bitcoin is held in cold storage with best-in-class regulated custodians.” That sentence names no custodian.
- Smarter Web: CEO Andrew Webley wrote on 30 October that Smarter Web “has not been impacted.” It has relationships with “five institutional-grade custodians: Fidelity, Coinbase, Kraken, Anchorage and Xapo.” On 2 November, Smarter Web said its bitcoin is currently held across Coinbase, Fidelity and Anchorage Digital. None of it is with Binance.
- Strive: Its treasury page read “Unencumbered BTC 100%” on 31 October. Chairman and CEO Matt Cole discussed the hack on Cointelegraph on 30 October.
- Strategy: Executive chairman Michael Saylor wrote on 30 October: “Binance has committed its own balance sheet to making customers whole. I expect it to deliver.” Strategy’s report for the quarter ended 30 June names Coinbase, Anchorage and Fidelity among its custodians.
Strategy held 848,517 bitcoin and Metaplanet 44,000 on 30 October. Strive held 43,000 on 23 October. Smarter Web held 2,850 on 31 October.
Keys and pledges are separate questions
Custody is who holds the keys. Cold storage means those keys are kept offline. Encumbrance is different: it means bitcoin is pledged as collateral and sits with a lender.
Strive’s 100% line answers the pledge question. It doesn’t say who holds the keys.
Smarter Web’s list answers the custody question. Its Coinbase credit facility stood at £16 million on 26 October, down from £20.8 million four weeks earlier, Webley wrote.
Neither that post nor Smarter Web’s analytics page says whether bitcoin secures the facility, and its statement of 2 November doesn’t either. Coinbase is also one of the three custodians that hold its bitcoin.
Strategy’s June-quarter report also covers insurance. Its custodians carry coverage “in excess of $320.0 million at Coinbase”. The figure is $100.0 million at Anchorage and “in excess of $100.0 million at Fidelity”.
That coverage is “in the aggregate and not per occurrence.”
The strongest objection applies to all four. A regulated custodian is still a third party, and none of these statements is an audit. They are what the companies say, not independent proof of reserves.
Another holder, Next Technology Holding (Nasdaq: NXTT), held 5,833 bitcoin on 30 September. On 30 October its board authorised the sale or pledge of those holdings, in one or more tranches.
Its quarterly report of 6 November says the company adjusted its strategy because of “heightened custody and market risks associated with digital assets”. It doesn’t currently expect to buy more bitcoin, and as of that report it had sold or pledged none.
Substantially all of its bitcoin is with Japan-based custodians, which the report doesn’t name. A sale would lower its bitcoin per share. A pledge would put the coins up as collateral.
Signal Take
Bitcoin per share counts coins. It doesn’t say who holds them or who else has a claim on them.
Smarter Web named its custodians. Strive published how much of its bitcoin is free of pledges. In the statements above, no company gives both answers.
The stakes sit with common shareholders. They own what’s left after debt and preferred, so a custody failure or a seized pledge lands on them. Publishing both answers, who holds the keys and how much is pledged, would let them price that risk.
Sources: Binance, Metaplanet analytics, Smarter Web analytics, Smarter Web statement of 2 November, Strive treasury page, Strive update of 26 October, Strategy KPIs, Strategy report for the quarter ended 30 June, Next Technology Holding report for the quarter ended 30 September.
Update, 2 November 2026: added Smarter Web’s statement of 2 November on where its bitcoin is held.
Update, 6 November 2026: added Next Technology Holding’s board decision of 30 October, from its quarterly report of 6 November.